This guide is shaped differently from the others, because Substack is not really a mail tool and Holder is not a publishing platform. Holder holds your people, your bookings and your sessions. It does not host an archive, a public publication page, or a paid-subscription product. So the honest first question is not how to export — it is whether this move is the right one.
Read this before you export anything
Three things Substack is holding that no export will release.
- Your archive and your address. The posts and the yourname.substack.com URL stay where they are. Everything you have ever linked to points at that address
- Recommendations. Writers recommending each other (Substack’s cross-promotion network) only works inside Substack. If a meaningful share of your list arrived that way, you are giving up your main source of new readers
- Paid subscriptions. Billing runs through Substack's own Stripe connection. Card details do not transfer, and there is no mechanism to hand the billing relationship to anyone else
If the newsletter is a way of staying in touch with a practice, Holder is a good home for the people and you keep writing wherever suits. If the newsletter is the practice, and paid subscriptions are the income, Holder is not a replacement and you'd be better looking at a publishing platform.
What comes with you
- Subscribers: yes, but no names. Substack's export is email address only for identifying a person — there's no name field to carry across.
- Permission to email (consent): not in the way you'd expect. When a free reader unsubscribes, Substack removes them from your list entirely rather than marking them deactivated, so there is no unsubscribed file to bring with you. Everyone in the export is there because they're still subscribed, which is newsletter consent, not automatically marketing consent in Holder — see the import step below for how to carry it across properly.
- Paid status: as a label only. Holder records who was paying you. It does not bill them, and the subscription does not continue.
- History: no. Opens, post views and comments stay with Substack.
Export from Substack
- Go to your Subscribers page and scroll to All subscribers
- Click the three dots above the subscriber list and select Export
- Choose All columns, not visible columns only
- You get: email address, subscription type (free, paid, complimentaryComplimentary (“comp”) means a subscription you gave away for free., gift), start date and activity. No names
Also take the full publication export from Settings > Exports > Create new export while you're there. It gives you your posts, your list and your stats in one compressed file (ZIP)ZIP packs several files into one download — open it to see the files inside.. You will not want to rewrite the posts from the web archive in two years.
Watch for: only import the people in this export. There is no separate list of people who left to check against, because Substack doesn't keep one.
If you have paid subscribers
Do this before you touch anything else, and do it personally.
- Write to each of them by name. If there are more than you can face writing to individually, that is a sign the paid tier is a real business and worth pausing over
- Decide what happens: wind the paid tier down with proper notice, or leave Substack running in paid-only mode while the rest of your work moves
- Whichever you choose, cancel the subscriptions yourself rather than letting them lapse into a service you have stopped writing for
Import to Holder
- Upload the subscriber spreadsheet file (CSV) as it downloaded. Holder tidies dates into one layout when you upload. Because there are no names, expect people to arrive with just an email address, flagged as incomplete, until you add names by hand
- Map the subscription-type column too. It arrives as a tag (a label you put on a person, like “workshop”, which you can use to pick who to email), so you can see at a glance who supported you
- For marketing consent: because everyone in this export is still subscribed, you can upload it and confirm in the consent box that they agreed to marketing — but only do that if your Substack sign-up made clear people would hear from you about other things beyond the newsletter itself. If it didn't, treat the list as your audience for now and get explicit consent before sending anything beyond the move announcement
- Duplicates are flagged side by side; the more restrictive opt-out wins
What you rebuild in Holder rather than import
- Sign-up forms and sequencesSequences are automatic emails sent at the right moment, such as a welcome or an after-session follow-up.
- Booking pages, session types, availability and packs, which Substack never had
- Under an hour for a working sign-up form and a welcome sequence
The last step
- Leave the Substack page up with a post explaining where you have gone and a link. Do not delete it — every link anyone has ever shared points there
- Send a test to yourself
- Add names to your regulars by hand as you go — Substack never gave you a spreadsheet of them, so this rebuilds itself gradually rather than all at once
Bringing across years of past bookings and records for you (a “deep history import”) is a paid one-off service, not part of a trial or a plan. If you want one, send us your export before you start a trial: we'll quote you for it, and tell you honestly what will and won't come with you either way.
Every feature, free for 30 days, no card. Import your client list in one sitting and take a real booking the same afternoon.
Start free trial