← Switching
Switching guides

Switching from MailerLite to Holder

MailerLite exports only the columns you can see on screen at the moment you press the button. Set your columns first and this takes twenty minutes; press export straight away and you'll get a thin file and won't notice until later.

What comes with you

  • Contacts: yes. Email addresses, names and every custom fieldSome tools call these “attributes” or “audience fields”. you've created — as long as you set the columns first.
  • Permission to email (consent): yes. Unsubscribed stays unsubscribed, with the unsubscribe date. Holder keeps a permanent do-not-email list (suppression list)People you must never email again. and checks it before every marketing email goes out.
  • History: no. Opens and clicks stay in MailerLite. They aren't in the subscriber export.

Export from MailerLite

Do this once for each status. There is no single file with everyone in it.

  • Go to Subscribers
  • Click Set columns and switch on every field you want. The export only includes the columns visible on the list at the time of exporting, and this is the step that quietly loses people's custom fields
  • Use the status drop-down to choose Active
  • Select all subscribers, not just the ones on the current page
  • Click Actions > Export CSV
  • Repeat for Unsubscribed, Bounced (couldn’t be delivered), Unconfirmed (signed up but never clicked the confirmation link) and Spam complaints

Take all five. The unsubscribed file carries the unsubscribe date, which is the record you want if anyone ever queries why they stopped hearing from you.

If your groups carry real meaning — a workshop list, a client list — export each group separately as well, so the structure can survive as tags (labels you put on a person, like “workshop”, which you can use to pick who to email) rather than being flattened into one list. See the import step for how.

Import to Holder

  • Upload all the files, one after another. If a file is all one kind of person (everyone unsubscribed, say), choose that in the “What does this file contain?” box so Holder records them correctly. A spreadsheet file (CSV) is all we need, and Holder tidies dates into one layout when you upload
  • Read the “Match your columns” step, and make sure the status column is mapped. That is the one carrying consent
  • A group file is only a list of people, so it carries no tag of its own. To keep a group as a tag, add a Tags column to that file with the group’s name on every row, upload it, match the column to Tags, and choose “Update the existing client” for the people already imported. The tag is added to their record
  • Combining this with a booking list or another mailing list (some tools call it an audience): Holder spots people already on your other list by their email address, and shows you what differs, detail by detail, before anything is saved
  • Duplicates are flagged side by side. If one record says unsubscribed and the other says active, the person stays unsubscribed

What you rebuild in Holder rather than import

  • Sign-up forms and sequencesSequences are automatic emails sent at the right moment, such as a welcome or an after-session follow-up.
  • Booking pages, session types, availability and packs, which MailerLite never had
  • Under an hour for a working sign-up form and a welcome sequence

What doesn't come with you

  • AutomationsAn automation is an email that sends itself when something happens, such as a welcome email after someone signs up.. No export exists. Note down what sets each email off and how long it waits before you close the account
  • SegmentA segment is a group of contacts picked out by a rule, such as everyone from one workshop. rules. Only the contacts export, not the logic that defined them. Write the rules down
  • Forms and landing pagesA landing page is a single web page made to get people to sign up or buy.. These stay with MailerLite. Screenshot anything you want to reproduce
  • Seeing who opened and clicked your emails. No opens, no clicks, no engagement scoring
  • Sites and e-commerce. If you built a MailerLite site or sell through it, that is a separate move and none of it comes across

The last step

  • Update every sign-up form and list link: website footer, link in bio, anything added elsewhere with code to show it on your own website (iFrame)Paste it into your website builder.
  • Send a test to yourself
  • Take one address you know unsubscribed in MailerLite and confirm Holder is suppressing it. Do this before your first real send

Bringing across years of past bookings and records for you (a “deep history import”) is a paid one-off service, not part of a trial or a plan. If you want one, send us your export before you start a trial: we'll quote you for it, and tell you honestly what will and won't come with you either way.

Try it on your own terms

Every feature, free for 30 days, no card. Import your client list in one sitting and take a real booking the same afternoon.

Start free trial
Switching from MailerLite to Holder · Holder