← Switching
Switching guides

Switching from Flodesk to Holder

The cleanest export of any mail tool here: one file, everyone in it, status in a column. Ten minutes of work, and the only thing to get right is exporting the whole audience rather than a segment.

What comes with you

  • Contacts: yes. Email addresses, names and your custom fieldsSome tools call these “attributes” or “audience fields”..
  • Permission to email (consent): yes. Unsubscribed stays unsubscribed. Holder keeps a permanent do-not-email list (suppression list)People you must never email again. and checks it before every marketing email goes out, so someone who left your list years ago cannot be emailed by accident later.
  • History: no. Opens and clicks stay in Flodesk. They aren't in the export.

Export from Flodesk

  • Go to Audience > Segments
  • Hover over All subscribers, not one of your segments
  • Click the three dots in the top-right corner of the card
  • Select Download CSV
  • The download link is emailed to the address you log in with, not to wherever you're sitting, and it expires after 24 hours. If you miss it, just run the export again

The file includes everyone in the selected segment, unsubscribed, bounced and spam-marked contacts included, with the status in a column. That is exactly what you want, and it is why this export is less work than most.

If your segmentsA segment is a group of contacts picked out by a rule, such as everyone from one workshop. carry real meaning — a workshop list, a client list, people from a particular event — export each of those separately as well. Segment membership is the only structure Flodesk holds, and one flat file loses it.

Import to Holder

  • Upload the All subscribers file as it downloaded. Holder tidies dates into one layout when you upload
  • A segment file is only a list of people, so it carries no tag of its own. To keep a segment as a tag (a label you put on a person, like “workshop”, which you can use to pick who to email), add a Tags column to that file with the segment’s name on every row, upload it, match the column to Tags, and choose “Update the existing client” for the people already imported. The tag is added to their record
  • Read the “Match your columns” step, and make sure the status column is mapped. That is the one carrying consent
  • Duplicates are flagged side by side. If the same person is on two lists and one says they have unsubscribed, they stay unsubscribed

What you rebuild in Holder rather than import

  • Sign-up forms and sequencesSequences are automatic emails sent at the right moment, such as a welcome or an after-session follow-up.
  • Booking pages, session types, availability and packs, which Flodesk never had
  • Under an hour for a working sign-up form and a welcome sequence

What doesn't come with you

  • Form and email designs. Flodesk's designs are the reason most people are there and none of it transfers. Screenshot anything you want to reproduce
  • WorkflowsA workflow here means the automatic reminder or follow-up emails set up in that tool.. No export exists. Note down what sets each email off and how long it waits before you close the account
  • Seeing who opened and clicked your emails. No opens, no clicks, no segment of people who haven’t opened or clicked. If the pre-built Unengaged Subscribers segment matters to you, export it separately now and tag it as described in the import step
  • Checkout and payment links. If you sell through Flodesk Checkout, that stays with Flodesk. Any live payment links need replacing before you close the account, or they break for the people holding them

The last step

  • Update every sign-up form and list link: website footer, link in bio, anything added elsewhere with code to show it on your own website (iFrame)Paste it into your website builder.
  • Send a test to yourself
  • Take one address you know unsubscribed in Flodesk and confirm Holder is suppressing it. Do this before your first real send

Bringing across years of past bookings and records for you (a “deep history import”) is a paid one-off service, not part of a trial or a plan. If you want one, send us your export before you start a trial: we'll quote you for it, and tell you honestly what will and won't come with you either way.

Try it on your own terms

Every feature, free for 30 days, no card. Import your client list in one sitting and take a real booking the same afternoon.

Start free trial
Switching from Flodesk to Holder · Holder